Immigration Argument Analysis

Words: 1371
Pages: 6
Open Document
Immigration is like a moving train in America, it is impossible to stop but whether or not it is beneficial to America. In the debate “Does Immigration Increase the Virtues of Hard Work and Fortitude in the United States,” many believe that immigration has taken away people's jobs and relies heavily on government benefits, arguing against immigration, Mark Krikorian begins his argument stating transportation makes immigrants less gritty, Krikorian believe that the change in transportations and community has lower the risk immigrants used to face while undertaking the dangerous journey thus making immigrants less gritty. Krikorian present his second argument by stating that “Welfare use among immigrants debunks the fable of the grit-bearing …show more content…
“For affluent, which included a disproportionate number of whites, the large labor pool provides them with a ready supply of gardeners, maids and nannies. For businesses in need of cheap manpower, the same is true” (Booth 82), in many cases certain races are hired for certain jobs due to stereotyping; Mexicans are believed to be good at taking care of plants, so many will hire them as gardeners. Although many believe that as more immigrant flood the cities there will be less job opportunity for the people in that area. In fact “there is no evidence to support this view… immigrants actually create more jobs than they fill. The job immigrants take are of course easier to see, but immigrants are often highly productive, run their own businesses, and employ both immigrants and citizens” (Cole 690). So rather than taking jobs, the increase of immigrants has created more jobs and with the wave of incoming immigrants, business will experience an increase in sales. “Immigrant workers spend their wages in U.S. businesses—buying food, clothes, appliances, cars, etc.—which sustains the jobs of the workers employed by those businesses. Moreover, businesses respond to the presence of new workers and consumers by investing in new restaurants, stores, and production facilities. The end result is more jobs for more workers” (American Immigration Council). But even if this misconception were true, as Binswanger stated in his article “Immigration Quotas vs. Individual Right,” “There is always more productive work to be done. If you can give your job to an immigrant, you can get a more valuable job” (628). Although immigrants do take jobs away from Americans, as more immigrants immigrate to America more jobs are created and with the immigrants taking all the low paying jobs, Americans will be motivated to search for a better
Show More

Related Documents: Immigration Argument Analysis

Arguments For Immigration Restrictions Analysis

necessary to solve issues with employment and the advancement of culture. Although there are many advantages to having open borders, we also have to acknowledge that developing a just immigration policy requires taking into account the opinions and concerns expressed by individuals like Hrishikesh Joshi. In recent years, immigration has gained attention as a contentious issue. While some contend that open borders are necessary to safeguard our nation, others think regulations are necessary. A few presidents…

Words 1198 - Pages 5

Analysis Of Ezra Klein's A Nativist Argument For Immigration

Ezra Klein talks about how having Immigrants in America will help the Economy in “A Nativist Argument for Immigration”. He also talks about what Economists tells us about immigrants like how they “raise wages for the average native-born, they make things cheaper for us to buy, without immigrants jobs would move to other countries, and that Americans should allow for much more highly skilled immigration”(paragraph 3). Giovanni Peri, an economist at the University of California says that “the mistakes…

Words 170 - Pages 1

1933 To 1939 Dbq

Point #1 Analysis: As seen in the document other countries should not place their internal difficulties with another country because they are not there to solve it. And this is exactly what the individuals were protesting about. Point #2 Argument: Protesting also led to many individuals wanting self - preservation. La Societe St-Jean Baptiste of the Quebec diocese, had signatures of 127, 364 people who were strongly against all immigration especially the Jews. They wanted…

Words 420 - Pages 2

Antonin Scalia Law School Case Study

best enable me to realize my long-term professional objective: to practice immigration law in the Washington, D.C. Metropolitan area. Scalia Law is truly unique in that it is the only law school in the D.C. Metro area that offers a comprehensive Immigration Law concentration, which specifically targets the D.C. legal market. I am, in particular, enthused about taking the following two course electives in the Immigration Law concentration: Refugee & Asylum Law and the Supervised Externship. These…

Words 262 - Pages 2

The Toulmin Arguments In Raise Wages, Not Walls

dissect arguments of authors across the world. The authors of the excerpt “Raise Wages, Not Walls” displayed effective and ineffective traits of good argumentation. They approach a very controversial problem that is being debated by congress. The authors argue about border control and law enforcement at the borders of the United States of America. The authors of this excerpt “Raise Wages, Not Walls” use the logical argumentation strategy and the Toulmin method is used by dissecting the argument to see…

Words 982 - Pages 4

Drug Trafficking Rhetorical Analysis

Rhetorical Analysis on: “Drug Trafficking, Gang Violence, and the U.S Immigration Crisis” Illegal immigration is not a new phenomenon in the United States of America. In fact the over whelming presence of these undocumented immigrants have left a forum for many discussions, hence enabling me to stumble upon an article written by Christopher Palmer. Palmer, a graduate with honors from George Mason University receiving a Bachelor of Arts and double major in History and Religious studies, is currently…

Words 646 - Pages 3

Charles O. Paullin's The Immigrant Contribution

professions, art, and culture. In paragraph 9, the author suggests, "Significant as the immigrant role was in politics and the economy, the immigrant contribution to the professions and the arts was perhaps even greater." Moreover, Charles O. Paullin’s analysis of the Dictionary of American Biography shows that immigrants are majority in various types of jobs. These statements reveal America's development through the efforts of many immigrants working in many fields. On the other hand,…

Words 237 - Pages 1

Environmental Effects Of Immigration

It is largely acknowledged that the environmental conditions of an immigrant source-country have a great impact on the number of out-flow migrants, nationally and internationally. Environmentalists suggest that an increase in immigration occurs with changing climate conditions (Martin 397)+. The term “environmental refugees,” coined in the 1980’s, describes refugees forced to leave their home region due to sudden or long-term environmental changes that compromise well-being. The United Nations High…

Words 1212 - Pages 5

Undocumented Immigration Research Paper

Some 393,000 people were deported in the fiscal year that ended Sept. 30, 2010, about half of whom had committed crimes, according to an Associated press analysis. The report, citing U.S Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) data, stated that 27,635 people were deported after receiving drunken driving citations, compared with 10,851 in the last full year of the Bush administration. In addition, 13,028 people were deported…

Words 1892 - Pages 8

Politics in Classroom Essay

and getting a good discussion going.” This is exactly what the goal was for this class and it was pretty clear from the start. Some of the discussions people did not agree with but that is just how it is sometimes in a college classroom setting. Immigration and gay marriage are two of the topics that come to me off the top of my head. We discussed these in class throughout the semester at some point and time. Whether they follow the basic “guidelines” of the article “Putting Politics Where It Belongs:…

Words 883 - Pages 4