Isolationist Debate Essay example

Submitted By redrock45
Words: 661
Pages: 3
Open Document
Hibbah Ali
January 29, 2014
History 4
Isolationist vs Internationalist Debate
Opening Statement:
America should not be involved in World War Two in any way. The First World War had devastating implications on our country and it would be unwise to go through that again. Many lives were lost and a great deal of money went to aiding other countries. After America helped Great Britain in World War One, we were bombed by Germany. This should be evidence that the United States should not assist Britain again or we run the risk of getting attacked. It is more beneficial for our economy and safer for our people to distance ourselves as much as possible from World War Two.

Argument:
In ww1 we were bombed by Germany when helping Great Britain. In the bombing of Lusitania 1,198 were killed and 128 of those passengers were Americans. We don't need a repeat of what happened. George Washington said that we should “avoid entangling alliances” and that “The Great rule of conduct for us, in regard to foreign Nations is in extending our commercial relations to have with them as little as possible.” Also after ww1, the Kellogg-Briand Pact was written to mesh the idea of non-intervention with that of the post-Versailles desire to end all wars. This shows that they didn't want to fight anymore and wanted what was best for everyone. Also the Special Committee thought “the intense competition among European and American munitions companies… tends to create a corrupt officialdom, and thereby weaken the remaining democracies of the world…” This would not be only hurting us but other countries as well. The Special Committee also found that by giving munition “there is a considerable threat to the peace and the civic progress of other nations” and that even if good sales were produced, the “effect of such sales is to produce fear and hostility… culminating in economic strain and collapse or war.”

Rebuttal:
"The security of America depends on supporting/joining the war"
This is not a fact, we are nowhere close in proximity to the conflict and there has not been any sign of an imminent threat towards our country from those engaged in the war since we have not been involved. What is a fact however, is that if our country does not remain neutral in this war, lives will definitely be lost no matter what. Though we still may be
Show More

Related Documents: Isolationist Debate Essay example

Spanish American War Research Paper

and Spain, as well as heightened competition among European powers for colonies in the Americas. The war had lasting consequences for the people living in the newly acquired territories, leading to debates over citizenship rights and the treatment of indigenous populations. The conflict also sparked debates within the US about imperialism and the country's role in global affairs, with…

Words 226 - Pages 1

How to have sex Essay

remained a major theme in American foreign policy as the country sought to avoid involvement in WWI for its first three years The prompt decision of the Wilson administration to declare neutrality at the outset of WWI showed that whilst there was a debate in America between those who had an expansive view of US foreign policy and those who did not, isolation from Europe reflected the sentiment of the vast majority of Americans. Until the sinking of the Lusitania and then the interception of the infamous…

Words 1439 - Pages 6

United States and Foreign Policy Essay

Union in 1989, many Americans began turning their attention toward domestic policy. This trend changed with the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001. Since then, foreign policy has returned to center stage, and politicians and candidates hotly debate foreign policy issues. An old adage states that politics stops at the water’s edge, meaning that the United States should not let political disputes influence foreign policy. In reality, though, partisan politics have a great impact on foreign policy…

Words 516 - Pages 3

Pearl Harbor Persuasive Essay

Pearl Harbor Paula Wigzell January 23,2016 History Final Draft December 7th, 1941 was a very tragic day for many people, the Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor, on the Hawaiian island of Oahu. Pearl Harbor is a lagoon harbor, meaning it is a shallow body of water separated from the ocean. Most of the harbor and the surrounding land is a United States Navy deep-water naval base. Japan launched a sneak attack on the U.S Pacific fleet at Pearl harbor, with torpedos and bomber planes. Eighteen naval vessels…

Words 1061 - Pages 5

World War Ii and Neutrality Acts Essay

the web page (below) presents: From Neutrality to War: The United States and Europe, 1921–1941 (4 Lessons) In the years after World War I Americans quickly reached the conclusion that their country's participation in that war had been a disastrous mistake, one which should never be repeated again. During the 1920s and 1930s, therefore, they pursued a number of strategies aimed at preventing war. At first the major players in this effort were American peace societies, many of which were part…

Words 504 - Pages 3

Preparedness For War Essay

Preparedness for War Civil Defence Evacuation in September 1939- Issues arising from evacuation, including treatment of evacuees and the varying attitudes towards them 140,000 patients sent home from hospitals to make way for expected air raid casualties An analysis of the extent to which the ARP scheme provided effective protection for civilians and the response of the emergency services to the Blitz Blackout procedures and the role of the ARP wardens Women’s Voluntary Service for Civil Defence…

Words 968 - Pages 4

Cold War Essay

between middle east/Europe communists vs. non-communists Stalin fears fascism GB- slaughtered 50,000 indians had many problems in India Yugoslavia 1946 Winston Churchill "Iron Curtain" speech - creates visual image for division of Europe - big debate in the US 1947 Truman Doctrine George Kennan (containment) announcing to the world the US will use any means possible for containment Marshall Plan - gave 12.5 billion dollars to European countries 1948 Germany and Berlin divided - western…

Words 611 - Pages 3

The DoubleEdged Sword Of The Right Essay

the group act as a friendly and non-violent organization that would eventually act as either a means to slowly turn the U.S. government into a powerful ally towards the destructive Nazi government across the Atlantic, or keep the U.S. under its isolationist policies in order to lessen the number of enemies the Germans would have to fight. However, the group would have to act quietly and not really have its name in any newspapers or other pieces of media attention. This is a stark contrast whereas…

Words 874 - Pages 4

The Lindbergh Legacy Summary

The book is about the rivalry between the most beloved and iconic men in America during that time, the patriotic aviator, Charles Augustus Lindbergh and one of the most lauded Presidents of United States, Franklin Delano Roosevelt. The plot of the goes about how Roosevelt and his administration destroy Lindbergh’s image as they smear him with accusations of being a Nazi sympathizer or an Anti-Semite. The book opens with a chapter named “The Lindbergh Legacy,” where the author gives an introduction…

Words 1717 - Pages 7

Fdr's Argumentative Analysis

resources of the United States and also make sure America would have all the equipment ready for emergency and to defend global democracy (9). By June 1940, Britain's ability to fight against Hitler seemed to be weakening. This brought many American isolationists to make the argument that if the United States entered the war, they would essentially be entering against Hitler's regime by themselves because all the other opposing forces would be too weak to help (10). However, Winston Churchill, the prime…

Words 1599 - Pages 7