Suicide and New York Essay

Submitted By wardy123
Words: 2958
Pages: 12
Open Document
Crisis 2011; Vol. 32(2):61–64
© 2011 Hogrefe Publishing
Editorial

Editorial
Cultural Context Is Crucial in Suicide Research and Prevention
Heidi Hjelmeland
Norwegian University of Science and Technology, Trondheim, and Norwegian Institute of Public Health, Oslo, Norway
According to Geertz (1973), “. . . there is no such thing as a human nature independent of culture . . . We are . . . incomplete or unfinished animals who complete or finish ourselves through culture . . .” (p. 49). And, in the words of
Markus and Hamedani (2007), “. . . biological beings become human beings through their engagement with the meanings and practices of their social world . . .” (p. 32).
Thus, the sociocultural context is crucial to peoples’ lives, which inevitably means that it also plays a crucial role in suicide. If we want to understand suicidal behavior and suicidal people, it is absolutely essential to take the cultural context into consideration in all kinds of suicidological research (e.g., Hjelmeland, 2010; Hjelmeland & Knizek,
2010; Hjelmeland & Knizek, in press). This should be selfevident. However, it turns out not to be, and in an endeavor to include a cultural perspective in suicidological research we face a number of challenges – conceptual, theoretical, methodological, ethical, and political challenges (Hjelmeland, 2010). One of the most important challenges, and the one to be discussed here, might be the current “biologification” of suicidology.
Among other sciences, psychiatry is one of the most prominent premise providers for suicidology; and there is no doubt that psychiatry, as well as behavioral sciences, have recently developed in a more biological direction
(Brinkmann, 2009). Thus, studies on biological factors
(e.g., genes, endophenotypes, neurotransmitters) are presently in demand (e.g., Mann et al., 2006), researchers are now describing the “suicidal brain” (e.g., Desmyter et al.,
2011), and various kinds of brain-imaging techniques are developing fast and maintained to be important also in suicidology. For example, Mann (2005) stated that “The clinician needs to know which depressed patient is at risk for suicide, and one promising direction is to begin using brain imaging to measure the predisposition to suicidal behavior
. . .” (p. 102). With this, we face some ethical challenges.
For instance, when and how is the information produced in such studies going to be used? If you are told that you have
© 2011 Hogrefe Publishing

a biological predisposition to suicide (or not), this information will inevitably have consequences for both you and your family and friends (Hjelmeland & Knizek, in press).
Moreover, such studies have their limitations. For instance,
Restak (2006) pointed out that correlations found in brainimaging research frequently – and inappropriately – are interpreted in terms of cause and effect relationships.
Furthermore, with the new brain-imaging techniques, psychiatry, and with it suicidology, may be heading toward (or back to?) a very mechanistic view of human beings. A potential consequence of finding biological markers for suicidal behavior is that this makes it rather easy to think of medication as the best/cheapest/easiest possible treatment available.
It may be considered easier to treat what is often referred to as “a chemical imbalance in the brain” with chemicals instead of spending a lot of resources on unveiling the reason(s) for this “imbalance,” which very well may be found in the person’s sociocultural environment, so that the patient should therefore rather be treated with alternative therapies. Take the current debate about whether the increased use/sales of antidepressants contributed to, or even caused, a reduction in suicide rates (e.g., Isacsson, Rich, Jureidini, & Raven, 2010).
Even though, according to Jureidini and Raven, the evidence base for such a relationship has proven methodologically weak, Isacsson and Rich maintain
Show More

Related Documents: Suicide and New York Essay

Physician Assisted Suicide Research Paper

Physician-Assisted Suicide Physician-Assisted Suicide or Euthanasia has been around since 5th century B.C. The Ancient Greeks and Romans, before the coming of Christianity, attitudes toward infanticide, active euthanasia, and suicide had tended to be tolerant. They were ethically bound to follow the Hippocratic Oath however during this time very few physicians followed it faithfully. Physician-Assisted Suicide was widely accepted in 5th century B.C. however, as technology, society, and medical…

Words 692 - Pages 3

Kate Spade Suicide Case

in an apparent suicide hanging. Police said Spade’s body was hanging from a scarf tied to a doorknob in her New York City apartment. A housekeeper discovered the body around 10 in the morning, according to an ABC News report. A suicide note was also found on the scene. Police declined to disclose further details about the note. “The contents of that note, as well as the physical state of the apartment and the comments of the witness, lend credibility that it is an apparent suicide,” said Dermot…

Words 331 - Pages 2

Essay about ENG1001 Noor Kamal Assignment2

Cather profoundly influence the behavior of the protagonist, Paul. The hostility Paul feels at school, his boring social life at home, his dream world in the Carnegie Hall and his final escape to the New York City all contribute to Paul’s isolation from the ordinary world and lead him to his suicide. Cather introduces the protagonist in the first physical environment, the school. It is here that Paul is interrogated by the school board for his “various misdemeanors” (Cather 235). This meeting presented…

Words 751 - Pages 4

Ethics and Oxford University Press Essay

1. Is it morally wrong to commit suicide? In this essay, I will argue if it’s morally wrong to commit suicide. By definition, suicide is “the action of killing oneself intentionally”1 , ‘intentionally’ being the word that tends to cause controversy with this topic, as it implies that the individual is conscious of his actions. Therefore, to argue this statement I will mainly analyse Hume and Aquinas’ arguments as well as other contributions from other philosophical authors. Aquinas’ main argument…

Words 1676 - Pages 7

Assisted Suicied Essay

Assisted Suicide Today there is a taboo about death. It seems morbid and dark to speak about death and if one does speak of death those who love them fear that they have a death wish. This has not always been the case The Roman Emperor Marcus Aurelius said in his philosophical diary Meditations said “Do not despise death but be well content with it, since this too in one of those things nature wills” (Aurelius) Studs Terkel mentioned in 2001 in “Will the Circle be Unbroken” that people want…

Words 533 - Pages 3

Character Analysis: All Quiet On The Western Front

In reality going to New York in order to live out this imaginative reality cannot repair the emotional damage that Paul suffers from this separation from “mother” and in fact causes it to continually worsen until Paul takes his own life. While in New York the mental repercussions of being separated from “mother” and removed from the world of art do not disappear. These repercussions, in…

Words 1627 - Pages 7

How Did The Great Depression Affected New York

broke in less than a day. The next day people were out of work because if they were working in the banks they were let go. How did the The great Depression affect New York? The Northeast was the most affected because New York is the capital of finances. New York had the most powerful banks in the United States. I think the Great Depression society by people did not have money to support their families and…

Words 272 - Pages 2

ESCALATION OF BULLYING AND SUICIDE IN COLLEGE Essay

ESCALATION OF BULLYING AND SUICIDE IN COLLEGE SHAWN A. FRED DEVRY UNIVERSITY ENGLISH 135 PROF: STROMP 12/15/2014 Due Date (12/17/2014 Shawn A. Fred Dec 11, 2014 English: 135 Final Paper Imagine this for a moment if you will, you’re walking to your dorm room from your last class of the day. You already had a rough day with all of your classes. To top things off you’ve been interested in this particular senior meanwhile you’re a freshman. Every time you summon enough guts to talk to her…

Words 594 - Pages 3

Suicide By Cop Research Paper

Abstract Mental illness is common underlying risk factors for suicides with over ninety percent of suicide victims have some form of mental health or substance abuse issues. For a suicidal person, the means of achieving his or her goal differ. Some, on the one hand, chose to commit suicide themselves. Others, on the other hand, chose to commit the act through the involuntary participation of others—like the police. Suicide-by-cop (SBC) is a phenomenon that has far reaching implication for the…

Words 2021 - Pages 9

Pros and Cons of Social Networking Essay

cyber bullying, and suicide. Archives of Suicide Research. 14(3). 206–221. Doi: 10.1080/13811118.2010.494133. Studies and anecdotal cases have demonstrated a link between suicidal ideas and experiences with bullying victimization. In 2007, a random pick of 1,963 middle school students that live in the united states completed a survey of internet use and experiences. The kids who experiences bullying or cyber bullying had more suicidal thoughts and were more likely to attempt suicide verses those who…

Words 300 - Pages 2