Essay Time Heraclitus

Submitted By jjeames
Words: 1726
Pages: 7
Open Document
The idea that you can have no such thing as moments in time is not possible in a human world. In Heraclitus' work he presents an understanding of time in which you have four basic premises: 1) That ‘X equals X’ at T1, meaning that X exists at a moment in time, hence being. 2) That time is infinitely divisible. 3) That because time is infinitely divisible you can have no ‘moments in time’ because for everything that you label a moment you will be able to further divide that moment. 4) That because you cannot have any moments in time at no time can ‘X equal X’ which results in a world not of being but in a world of becoming. While this is logically correct in the sense that all the premises accurately reflect a logical conclusion we are concerned with presenting the accuracy of these premises in the first. Heraclitus uses the metaphor of a river to explain his ideas about the constant flux of the world and the constant change that takes place. Plato notes that according to Heraclitus, it is impossible to step into the same river twice. By this he means that the river is constantly changing and that the person entering the river would never be able to step into the same water twice, for this water would have been removed down river and replaced by new water. In order for this to be possible he stands in support of an ever changing world with no definable moments in time. This ever-changing phenomenon is not without faults, among them assumptions that time takes place regardless of humans and disregarding the fact that time and its divisibility is contingent upon the constructs usefulness to humans.
In order for this ever-changing world to be rational it must be exhibited by physical matter held in a vacuum otherwise this pretense does not hold up well in the physical world. We shall start with the first premise. ‘X equals X’. This premise may come across as straightforward but must be explained here for it has implications on the rest of the argument. The statement of ‘X equals X’ is a statement of Being while ‘X does not equal X’ stands to mean that the item is nonexistent. Unlike statements of Becoming, Being implies that at a specified time, T1, a physical item actually existed whether in a physical or metaphysical form. This is juxtaposed to a statement such as Heraclitus' that we live in an ever-changing world. His world view is a clear statement in favor of Becoming in which we take a relative existence dependent upon what is exerting power upon us and the setting that we find ourselves in. According to Heraclitus, at all times then we are simply Becoming with no moment of Being. Quite backward I think.
The second premise of the argument is that time is infinitely divisible. The idea of having time being infinitely divisible is not useful to humans. Because, as will be displayed below, time is relative and dependent upon humans for existence, time is simply a creation that we utilize because it is convenient and advantageous for us to do so. The idea that you can have no moments in time is not possible in a human world. If, as has been presented, time is infinitely divisible then it would be true that you can have no moments in time. However, in order for items and objects to interact with each other there must be a specified time, relative to the participants, at which two things come into contact. Therefore time must not be infinitely divisible, for time is relative to the object taking part in an action and is therefore a mere imposition of an abstract, unrealistic idea upon physical items. Therefore we must consider time as an abstract idea and decide if it is: Dependent or Independent, Relative or not. Let us first begin by examining the relativity of time.
It is my understanding that time is relative to the participants in a given situation and that time is imposed upon items through their relation to those who witness the event. In the cases of black holes we, who are not entering a black hole but observing
Show More

Related Documents: Essay Time Heraclitus

Heraclitus Paper

LET THE RIVERS FLOW AND FIRES BURN; HERACLITUS Abbigail Fuller Humanities Foundations 2210, Composition November 13, 2014 Fuller 2 If one were to ‘google’ the term philosophy today, the first thing the researcher would be faced with would not be about philosophy at all. Instead, the curious internet searcher would first be shown a cosmetic company that creates an array of lotions, hand soaps, and products that are advertised to make a woman’s skin as touchable as an infant’s hindquarters. The…

Words 1258 - Pages 6

Heraclitus Argument Essay

Heraclitus believed the world was in a constant, systematic state of change and although everything is in a ceaseless state of flux and change, the change is not merely just a random, haphazard occurrence. All change occurs in accordance with certain universal principles of reason. Heraclitus’s emphasize was on pattern, order and structure which were not based on physical objects but reason, also known as logos. Heraclitus believed in the cyclic recurrence of all things, including human life. He…

Words 834 - Pages 4

How Does Heraclitus Change

Heraclitus was a member of a wealthy aristocratic family, but he refused to be submissive to such a lifestyle and became disillusioned to the society he lived in. This made him flee to live in the mountains. It was here that Heraclitus came to discover/believe that the universe was moderated by a divine logos (logic/reason). Heraclitus noted that the logos kept the universe within perfect balance between opposites, such as day and night, hot and cold, or wet and dry. The reformations made Heraclitus…

Words 624 - Pages 3

The Life and History of Plato Essay

movement that led to the execution of Plato's mentor, Socrates. Together these events forever altered the course of Plato's life and Heraclitus was also born in the sixth century BCE, he was an Ephesian, who, by all accounts, was not a terribly social creature he was of course the most famous for his assertion that everything is always in constant flux. Heraclitus took particular interest in the physical world, that is, “things of which there is sight, hearing, experience He believed that our knowledge…

Words 1523 - Pages 7

History: Metaphysics and Reality Essay

the most with Heraclitus and his definition of the arche. I love how he bases his definition on the subject of time, and that “all is becoming.” I agree with his conjecture that he describes reality as always moving forward, because we cannot step into the same river twice. That means that every second is different from the last and no second can be the same. I find this to be the most relatable to my reality because time controls everything that I do. There just is not enough time in the day. Our…

Words 439 - Pages 2

Milesian Monists: Viewed Water As The Basic Roots Of Greek Philosophy

2c. Heraclitus Born c.540 BCE in Ephesus. Heraclitus was very critical of other philosophers. Although, he proposed a notion of cosmic harmony rather like Pythagoras’, and a notion of intellectual divinity like Xenophanes’. Known as the “the riddler”. In his aphorisms, everyday objects and events are used to reveal the hidden nature of the cosmos. Heraclitus imagines the whole cosmos as an eternal fire. He says that other elements are exchanged for fire in a cosmic cycle. Heraclitus claimed…

Words 1197 - Pages 5

History Of Greek Civilization

to tell that the author thinks highly of Greek civilization. Maybe that’s why he chooses to discuss the origins and development of it at the very beginning of this book. As far as I am concerned, this chapter mainly talks about religions in ancient times and how they guided people to live. There was a considerable difference between Egyptian and Babylonian theology. The Egyptians were preoccupied with death, and believed that the souls of the dead descend into the underworld, where they are judged…

Words 4314 - Pages 18

Before Socrates Essay

Jessica Anderson Phil 1301-43002 Critical Response: Philosophy Before Socrates Prior to Socrates, many philosophers emerged themselves in critical thinking on questions that were profound for their times. For this very reason, many philosophers turned toward personal new and innovative ways to answer their questions. To this very day, both scientists and philosophers continue to place value on the reasoning and theories that were formed by the philosophers that came before Socrates. Thales…

Words 1138 - Pages 5

Same River Twice Meaning

Quotes from the past are the knowledge passed by those who pondered upon a subject for great deal of their time, therefore, they must be taken with a lot of consideration, and understand that each quote offers wisdom and knowledge that we could fathom without sacrificing our time, in a way like the books do for our minds, they nurture it by helping it to expand. The quotes "You can never step into the same river twice" and "What exists is uncreated and imperishable (unchanging) for it is whole and…

Words 984 - Pages 4

The Importance Of A Project Manager

distinguished and rewarding, has resulted in cumbersome hours and a void in the presence of my son’s routine. My desire is to complete this next part of my educational training and parlay it into a professional move that would allow me to spend more time at home with my family as well as move them closer to my parents and siblings in California. How many people have heard the expression, “Home is where the heart is” and disputed it? I believe raising my family in the presence of other relatives would…

Words 1089 - Pages 5