Women in the infantry Essay

Submitted By Stephen-Greenwell
Words: 1719
Pages: 7
Open Document
Women in the infantry
Stephen C Greenwell
COMM215
March 2, 2015
Colette Wanless-Sobel

With the passing of so many bills and orders in today's government, the largest standing issue is whether or not women should be allowed into the infantry roles or Military Occupation Specialties (MOS). Women should not be permitted into the infantry MOS for a number of reasons. First and foremost, the women who find themselves wanting a challenge are not able to pass the initial test of the Combat Endurance Test (CET). Secondly, the female body isn’t made for the stresses and rigors of extreme weight lifting, lack of sleep and overall mental preparedness to serve in an infantry MOS. Lastly, the Infantry Brotherhood will decline, and sexual assault/harassment cases will spike. At the end of this essay, you will be left knowing that women in the infantry isn't about everyone being equal, but everyone having a particular job to accomplish without putting others into unnecessary harms way.
Women of the Infantry Recently, we have seen a lot of commotion about whether of not women should be allowed in the infantry MOS. The Marine Corps has been doing a lot of testing on this subject to seek out volunteers for them to be integrated into the infantry MOS’s. Since the beginning of the integration experiment that started in June 2014, the Infantry Officers Course has seen 26 female Marines volunteer for the program. Of those 26 female Marines officers, not one has yet been able to pass the Combat Endurance Test. The Male Marines, who are subjected to the same CET, also struggle to make it through to become infantry officers. The course that started at the beginning of January 2015 has dropped 15 men out of a 118-person course. “Opportunities for female enlisted Marines to cycle through Infantry Training Battalion for seven MOS-specific ground combat training programs will also end soon, the newspaper reported. Marine Corps statistics shows that out of 240 volunteers, 106 were successful" (Ernst, 2015, para. 4). This number is widely misrepresented.
Unlike, the Officer Candidate Course that is only located in Quantico, VA, enlisted Marines are separated into two different training camps. All potential male Marines, or Recruits, west of the Mississippi River are sent to Marine Corps Recruit Depot (MCRD) San Diego, Ca. All male Recruits East of the Mississippi River are sent to MCRD Parris Island located in Beaufort, South Carolina. For the female Recruits, they will all go to MCRD Parris Island for training, regardless of where they originated. Everyone can tell you the differences between the West and East coast terrains. The fact that all 106 female Marines have passed the enlisted infantry course is significantly due in part because they have only been trained on the flat swamps of East Coast United States. Move those females to the steep mountainsides of Camp Pendleton in Southern California, and you'll see those numbers sharply decrease.
Female health in combat roles Let's say for instance that some women were able to make it into a infantry unit or MOS. Those women wouldn't last long, medically, and I believe psychotically as well. For instance, women have a similar muscle mapping structure compared to men but each is built for specific duties. Male and female metabolisms are entirely different. Men tend to burn calories at a much faster rate, than women. Women store extra fat in their breasts, hips and buttocks to provide for the child during pregnancy. Men benefit from the faster metabolism resulting in being much stronger and agile beings compared to women. This is an essential factor when it comes to combat. The differences between man and woman are slight but when you start adding addition weight to the person, prolonged patrols, lack of sleep, lack of showers/toilets and those differences grow exponentially. A female, company grade combat, engineer officer with five years of service, multiple combat deployments has pleaded her
Show More

Related Documents: Women in the infantry Essay

Persuasive Essay On Women In The Military

Women have been serving in the U.S. Military for hundreds of years but when the U.S. Government tries to further break the carrier barrier for women by allowing them to be Marine Corps infantry officers, America has a long debate over the issue. Although I always hope for gender equality, I have to say that women should not be Marine Corps infantry officers and the government should not be able to draft women for the Marine Corps infantry, in the event of an emergency. The physical differences between…

Words 937 - Pages 4

Buffalo: American Civil War and Infantry Regiments Essay

history of the brave men and women who overcame extreme adversity while gallantly fighting the great American wars. African Americans have served proudly in every great American war. In 1866, through an act of Congress, legislation was adopted to create six all African American Army units. The units were identified as the 9th and 10th cavalry and the 38th, 39th, 40th and 41st infantry regiments. The four infantry regiments were later reorganized to form the 24th and 25th infantry regiments. These fighting…

Words 1602 - Pages 7

Women Should Be Allowed To Engage In Front Lines Of War

your essay below: An Over-due Chance Recognized or not, women have been on the front lines of war since the beginning. They have served as cooks and nurses, both of which can be harmed just as easily as a soldier. So why not go ahead and make it official? Women want to be able to join the combatant ranks throughout all the branches of the military. They can’t join due to a ban on women not being able to be on the front lines of battle. Women should be allowed to engage in direct ground combat because…

Words 1373 - Pages 6

Women In Combat Argumentative Essay

Today, there’s an issue with women fighting in combat. Women shouldn’t be able to fight in combat due to their physical differences, rape, pregnancy, and attrition rate. Excluding women from combat is similar to excluding older people from active service. A poll taken by USA Today states that “Forty-four percent of Americans believe that women should not be assigned to infantry units” (Attitudes Toward Women in Combat). Infantry units are soldiers that fight on foot, example front line soldiers.…

Words 1298 - Pages 6

Military Allow Women In Combat

Should the Military Allow Women to Serve in Combat? Both women and men should be allowed to serve in combat. As of 2013, women were not allowed to have combat roles that men had in the military. This needed to change, and with the help of the Secretary of Defense, Leon Panetta, the ban on women serving in ground combat units was repealed and opened more than 250,000 previously closed positions to women. Panetta wanted to ensure that the Defense Department provided a path towards leadership for the…

Words 651 - Pages 3

Essay Speech 2

you about women in the United States Military and how far they have come since being allowed to enlist in the military. James Brown recorded a song in 1966 called It’s a Man’s, Man’s Man’s world, but that is not true anymore, women are in the limelight now and not just in the shadows of the man. Women in the U.S. Military have come a long way since the beginning of the 1940’s, beginning way back to the early years when women were almost never recognized until most recently where women are now the…

Words 863 - Pages 4

Tomb Of The Unknown Soldier Research Paper

seven days a week, and 365 days a year (Ashabranner 68). The Third Infantry is important because it’s only infantry unit that is allowed to march with bayonets on rifles. Have rmp duties like providing protection for nation's capital during national emergencies, also providing escorts for presidents. They are responsible for conducting all military funerals in Arlington National Cemetery. Most important honor given to the Third Infantry is guarding the Tomb of Unknown soldiers (Ashabranner 68-69).Each…

Words 920 - Pages 4

Women's Role In Ww1

Some women joined the Navy or Marines and even became nurses while others were giving supplies out to Europe. Women also worked in munition factories. Women had to do a lot of work while their men were in the war. During the war women had to get jobs because most of the men went to war. American military women have served stateside and overseas on the eastern and western war fronts. Over 230 bilingual civilian…

Words 1974 - Pages 8

Women In The Military Research Paper

Introduction Women have found ways to fight for the US military for its entire existence. In the beginning women had to disguise themselves as men to fight in combat. This has steadily changed over the years. Today, women are allowed to work in all military positions, including as infantrymen. Women In Military Roles Revolutionary & Civil War Women worked as nurses, cookes, laundresses or disguised themselves (The Colonial Williamsburg Foundation). Deborah Sampson: The First Female Soldier (The…

Words 938 - Pages 4

My Lai Massacre Research Paper

should never be forgotten. Innocent Vietnamese civilians were brutally killed by American soldiers, only following orders from their lieutenant. The massacre entailed the slaughter of livestock, destruction of food supplies, brutal rape and beating of women, and so much more. Estimates of more than 500 civilians were killed during the massacre. The massacre wasn’t reported immediately until a year after, and it finally came to light. Because of this, the U.S. was divided over the Vietnam War because of…

Words 225 - Pages 1