Couples Only? Essay

Submitted By laurengarcia
Words: 968
Pages: 4
Open Document
Lauren Huber-Garcia
Mrs. Peterson
English 1301-341
February 19, 2013
Couples Only?
What’s the deal? Is it the fact that there are heterosexual couples that have rights and benefits available to them unlike the homosexual couples? Or is it based on whether or not people, no matter their sexual preference, are in a marital relationship with another being. This article tries to persuade citizens, especially singles, that giving benefits and rights to married couples, gay or straight, is unreasonable. The author comes from a singles person’s perspective, which “don’t share in he deal given to married couples” and bears a different viewpoint dealing with the gay marriage issue (Harrop 675). In Froma Harrop’s “Gay, Straight: What’s The Deal”, she explains “the deal” through his use of the appeals to Logos, Pathos, and Ethos. In this article Harrop uses facts as examples to show that it’s neither fair nor right that married couples are allotted privileges that single Americans do not. Take the lesbian couple for example, “…the women filed a medical-malpractice lawsuit. One of them suffered from advanced breast cancer, which the suit claimed, a doctor had failed to detect. The other wanted to collect for “loss of consortium.”(Harrop 675).
The author belittles the couple for the “collection of monetary” which makes it seem as if she is blaming the use of the benefits that are given to married couples. The author uses this fact and compares it to those people who are close but are in a non-marital relationship. “You can’t read this without thinking about similar hurts being felt all the time in non-marital relationships… Why can’t they sue for loss of companionship, also?” (Harrop 675). On the pathos she uses emotion and an angry tone that makes her irritation over gay marriage clear as well as use the word “you” and “us” to make the examples seem more real and personable. “In doing this, the senators have earned my gratitude- though for reasons not directly related to gay rights. Rather the move will spare us all some of the repetitive back-and-forth that has characterized this debate.” (Harrop 675). This technique Harrop uses allows for the author and the single American audience to meet in the middle and find some common ground on this issue. “What really rankles me...” and “So much attention is paid to married couples that most of the public- including single people themselves- think of unmarried adults as a marginal minority.” Further show her anger of the treatment towards the single Americans (Harrop 675). Another use of pathos is show in the example about the sisters. “Government should have no interest in a citizen’s marital status. It certainly has no business sending a bigger tax bill to cohabiting sisters that to a man-and-wife team reporting the same income and deductions as the sisters.” with this the author implies that the status of the relationship does not set the morality of the government and their beliefs (Harrop 676). By using the choices of words she does, its allows for the audience to see how compassionate she is about this issue and that it is really important to her that she portrays that to her readers. What helps make this article a persuasive article is the ethos appeal. “Quickie marriages get more legal respect that friendships lasting decades.”(Harrop 675). This helps her portray that society does not approve of this certain action just to receive the benefits. Harrop gains the credibility and the sense of confidence by using examples that everyday people in society can relate to. For example Britney Spears “An hour after Britney Spears gets hooked to her next husband, the federal government will shower her with all sorts of rights and benefits not available to the man who has spent eight years caring for a
Show More

Related Documents: Couples Only? Essay

Poetry Response to "Novella" Essays

In this poem, Rich is depicting a domestic dispute between a man and a woman, that seems to be fairly routine for the couple in question. It is never stated whether the couple is married or not, but I inferred that they are due to them living and having children together. I connected with this poem because I have been a witness to many domestic disputes, and the effects that they have on the participants. I also have an issue with anger and arguing in my own relationships. When Rich says that “She…

Words 384 - Pages 2

The Gyroscopic Effect

used in air or sea vehicles such as air planes and ships, wherein always external disturbing couple is acting on the vehicle. Thus, for the stability of such vehicles it is essential to neutralize the effect of external disturbing couple which can be done by applying equal and opposite couple .Accordingly, to generate equal and opposite reactive couple it is essential to vary the magnitude and direction of velocity of precession. In the case…

Words 1154 - Pages 5

Same Sex Adoption Assignment Essay

creating a climate in which same sex couples are raising children in an increasing number. Same sex couples may become parents through a number of ways like heterosexual intercourse, donor insemination or other reproductive procedures, surrogacy arrangements and adoption. For same sex couples, adoption is either in the form of known or unknown but it represents a significant aspect for family formation. Adoption for same-sex couples in Australia is currently only available in Western Australia, the…

Words 2279 - Pages 10

Essay on Equity: Same-sex Marriage and Marriage Equality

days before same sex couples can legally marry after the Circuit Court struck down Prop 8. Attorney General Kamala Harris then urged the court to act sooner. Meanwhile, Governor Jerry Brown directed all California counties to issue marriage licenses to same-sex couples when the Circuit Court acts. For the first time since Prop 8 was passed, same sex couples would have the same right to marry as heterosexual couples had enjoyed for centuries. This court ruling gave all couples regardless of sexual…

Words 521 - Pages 3

Arranged Marriage Abuse International Immigration System

“There’s a difference between interest and commitment, when you are interested in doing something, you do it only when it’s convenient, when you are committed to something, you accept no excuses, only results.” Kenneth Blanchard. Arranged marriage predominantly infer the picture of two individuals being obliged to get married, in some cases individuals of significantly different ages, or marriages were a dowry or cash are included. The bride and groom might have not met in person or talked before…

Words 1490 - Pages 6

Gay Adoption Research Paper

and no matter the physical components of the family be it two dads or two moms everyone has the right to a family. Homosexual couples adopting should be legal in the United States of America because, more children will have a better future and that leads to a much more successful country We having so many children and youth in foster care and legal adoption by gay couples would help with this situation. Currently there are an estimated of 518,000 children in the foster care program. About 40,000…

Words 1031 - Pages 5

Jim Markson Vs Gay Law

According to the state of New York, my client, Jim has been legally married to his husband since December 2011, in New York. Due to that, the married couple are not recognized to them as married. My client, Markson will be suing the federal government for the money that has been lost in the past 15 years for not being recognized as a married couple. Adding to that, Jim also wants the right to file taxes with his partner in the future, giving them the advantage to get their money back as well. By…

Words 1039 - Pages 5

Gay Marriage Persuasive Essay

pursuit of Happiness.” This is not the case for all people, for example, same-sex couples. Homosexual couples are not given the same rights as their heterosexual counterparts in all 50 states. Currently, only 37 states have legalized gay marriage, which leaves us with 13 states who are still stuck in ancient times. Gay marriage should be legalized in all 50 states because it is a basic human right, same-sex couples should be able to enjoy the benefits of marriage, and they would contribute a financial…

Words 827 - Pages 4

Same Sex Marriage 10 17 2014 Essay

love whether they're of the same gender, stripped, and etc. Homosexual couples and heterosexual couples only difference is the gender of the person they love, homosexual couples should have the same right to marry that heterosexual couples do because homosexual couples are more likely to adopt one of the many children in foster care and family values that most would believe true. Homosexual couples and heterosexual couples only difference is the gender of the person they love. “There are significant…

Words 933 - Pages 4

Infertility Research Paper

One in six couples at a childbearing age have fertility issues. Infertility is the inability to carry a pregnancy to a live birth and to achieve pregnancy after a year of regular sexual relations. The cause of infertility is varied, and can involve issues with the male, female or a combination of the two, and may include problems with the production of sperm or eggs, the structure or function of male or female reproductive system, and hormonal and immune conditions. The diagnosis of infertility can…

Words 1762 - Pages 8