Differences In The Devil's Arithmetic

Words: 611

Pages: 3

Open Document

Was she young? Was she old? Was Rivka really her cousin? After perusing the Devil’s Arithmetic and Watching the movie, I perceived numerous differences and resemblances between the two versions of the story, “The Devil’s Arithmetic”. Various parts of the movie weren’t even present in the book at all, and vice versa. Granted, there were a few similarities. There were the general, accustomed ideas, such as “Never forget”, which is a fundamental reason why Jane Yolen wrote this inspiring book. In the book, Hannah Stern is a limited, slightly immature teen who is conventionally done with family Jewish Seders. She has overtaxed her brain with remembering and doesn’t deduce the importance of getting together. But all that is refined when she is shifted into the past after opening the apartment door for the Prophet Elijah. Going to a wedding, then getting sent into the concentration camps for “resettlement” is what preceded. At the end of the book Hannah ends up saving Rivka, her friend, and returns to her home. In the movie, on the other hand, we see an older girl, in her late teens, who is sarcastic, irascible, and plain out disgusted she has to go to the Seder. She is taken aback, of course, to find herself in the middle of the …show more content…
Clearly, these camps were no picnic. Death and Destruction had been just around the corner. Hannah was still dispirited about going to the Seder, and she was still Aunt Eva’s favorite niece. But apart from that, you have hope that they will survive another day, Hannah encourages the POW’s by telling them stories, and the certainty that Hannah will return home and Rivka will survive. The plot, where Hannah is transported into the past, is alike. There were bounteous differences, but you can definitely contemplate the harrowing journey throughout the

Touching Spirit Bear Literary Analysis

Literary Analysis of Touching Spirit Bear and The Devil’s Arithmetic Devil’s Arithmetic and Touching Spirit Bear are very similar and different because of characters, setting, conflict, and theme.Touching Spirit Bear and Devil's Arithmetic are two books that have many different similars and differences. While Touching Spirit Bear and Devil's Arithmetic share the same theme of survival they still so very different. because of their characters, and plots.…

Words 433 - Pages 2

Touching Spirit Bear Literary Analysis

beating up Peter, Cole gets sent to a remote island for a year so he can heal mentally. On the other hand, in the book, Devil’s Arithmetic, Hannah gets stuck in the past and becomes Chaya. She gets placed in a concentration camp because she's jewish ad has to try to remember her Hannah life to know what is happening. While the protagonist in Touching Spirit Bear and Devil’s Arithmetic come to similar conflicts, internal and external, the theme overall is different. In the book, Touching Spirit Bear,…

Words 417 - Pages 2

Comparing Touching Spirit Bear And Devil's Arithmetic

Imagine: you’re trying to survive during 1942 in Nazi Germany or even a deserted island off the Alaskan Coast! In Devil’s Arithmetic, a Jewish girl by the name of Hannah goes back to 1942 and tries to survive in a concentration camp and starts to forget about the future. Another book called Touching Spirit Bear is about a stereotypical teenager by the name of Cole Matthews, who disrespects adults and kids. He finds himself going to Circle Justice after an attack on a kid. He goes to an island off…

Words 389 - Pages 2

Jane Yolen The Devil's Arithmetic

really made me understand what happens in the camps and what the people went through. Remembering and having hope is how you will make it out alive. For the most part the book and the movie have the same summary. Here is what the summary is. The Devil’s Arithmetic was written by Jane Yolen and her story was very interesting and made you really understand and pay attention when you read it. I say that because her book is very detailed and you have to read to catch…

Words 804 - Pages 4

Touching Spirit Bear Book Report

Touching Spirit Bear, T.S.B, and The Devil’s Arithmetic ,D.A, are 2 books that have environments that are dangerous that have some similarities and some differences. Let’s compare them! First the backstory of the books, starting off with T.S.B. T.S.B is about a boy named cole that is on the wrong side of the law. Prision won’t work for him so he is sent to circle justice which is a Native American form of justice , originating in Canada that seeks healing in contrast to the regular punishment ways…

Words 497 - Pages 2

Devil's Arithmetic Movie And Book Comparison Essay

emotional plotline in her book The Devil’s Arithmetic published in the year of 1988 that keeps readers on their seats and turning every page. This, in turn, has touched so many lives that the movie The Devil’s Arithmetic, directed by Donna Deitch--which came out ten years later--was based on it to help depict the story of a girl who experiences the sadistic life of the concentration camps. Although both have succeeded in portraying the overall story, the conspicuous differences between the book and the movie…

Words 1628 - Pages 7

The Devil's Arithmetic Movie And Book Comparison Essay

The Devil’s Arithmetic book and movie are filled with many pieces in the puzzle to the holocaust and share numerous similarities. However, many prefer the book because of it’s differences in tone, characters, and more. are filled with many pieces in the puzzle to the holocaust. To begin, in both the book and the movie, Hannah refuses to remember and celebrate religious traditions. She rather spent time with her friends. At the Seder, when Hannah opens the door for Elijah, she realizes she is not…

Words 457 - Pages 2

Essay On The Devil's Arithmetic

The Devil’s Arithmetic is a gruesome story about the holocaust using fiction to explain it to the readers. Both the movie and the book are hitting this point straight on the head. When the hammer hits the nail, this novel and movie can use that fictional part of the story to create an image for the readers to understand what actually occurred. What actually happened can’t be explained in book form, let alone having another person who survived tell their story. Both similarities and differences are…

Words 605 - Pages 3

Comparison/Contrast: The Devil's Arithmetic

The Devil’s Arithmetic Compare/Contrast Essay The Devil’s Arithmetic was not about the devil, but about the horror that many faced, and that many died from. Hannah, the main character, is Jewish, and yet she doesn't know of the struggle her religion went through in the 20th century. In the book, Hannah learns all about her family’s past and what happened to the lot of Jews. The book also has a movie made off of it. There are many differences, but they both show Hannah the significance of remembering…

Words 337 - Pages 2

The Devil's Arithmetic And The Boy In The Striped Pajamas

One great example of this is when writers use historical fiction to explain what could have happened to someone in a past event. Both historical fiction novels, The Devil’s Arithmetic by Jane Yolen and The Boy In The Striped Pajamas by John Boyne use the effect of strong relationships in their writing. Shown in The devil’s Arithmetic by Jane Yolen we read on page 163, “She couldn’t look at her aunt anymore, that familiar, unfamiliar face.” This shows a powerful moment in the novel when Hannah, the…

Words 1024 - Pages 5