Near Death Argument Analysis

Words: 1297
Pages: 6
Open Document
Going back to the first argument of corroborated veridical NDE perceptions it is important to present the opposing side of view. This argument is one of the most significant and most-used due to how difficult it is to argue against. As a review, some people that experience near death experiences are able to relay the medical procedures, conversations and things that surround their body while they were clinically dead. The naturalistic argument against these occurrences is mainly that they are good guesses. If it is simply only a good guess then should there not be an explanation for the ability to accurately “guess” during an NDE as well? Good guessing is a total sub-par explanation for near death experiences. To put it to test, Dr. Satori …show more content…
Think of a dream. Most dreams end abruptly, there is never a final ending to the storyline. Stories cut off, conversations cut short. And this is reasonable because we expect them to abruptly end when we wake up. So what is the reasoning behind the connection of near death experiences to dreams/hallucinations? How could a near death experience be a dream or hallucination if they consistently have closure? If we were to follow this point of view, near death experiences would end when sedation is stopped or when a patient is resuscitated. Going back to my second argument, another commonality amongst NDEs is that people are brought back or involved in their return to their bodies. In most cases, their return to consciousness is directed by a spiritual being. A good response to this claim would be “what about the people in NDEs that weren’t brought back by spiritual beings?” Good question, but Miller’s studies reported that “not one of these NDErs reported a disruptive ending. Indeed, the majority spoke of a conversation ending in a decision to return, or just knowing that it was time to return. But even in cases that didn’t include a conscious decision to return, I saw no NDE that was cut off abruptly, like mid-sentence” (Miller 44-45). Near death experiences could be compared to movie scripts; they run their course and end in an appropriate manner. Because of this, it would be better to label near death experiences as a encounter with the “other side” rather than labelling it as a common dream or
Show More

Related Documents: Near Death Argument Analysis

Death Penalty Through Life of David Gale Essay

Paper: The Life of David Gale makes many arguments against the death penalty throughout the movie showing how far the characters in the movie will go to promote this cause they hold near and dear to their hearts. David Gale plays a Professor in the philosophy department, but after a series of unfortunate events he ends up on death row even though through his entire career he made himself a known advocate for the Death Watch; which was an anti-death penalty organization that frequently fought for…

Words 959 - Pages 4

M. Therese Lysaught's Argument

details of this case provided below, M. Therese Lysaught judged that the actions of the hospital in this situation did not classify as a direct abortion. M. Therese Lysaught defends argument through in five ways. First, she cites the magisterial teaching embodied by Catholic Healthcare West, and supports her argument with teachings of magisterial documents. Second, she analyzes the moral object of the action through the works of St. Thomas in his Summa Theologica. Third, she explores the principle…

Words 1134 - Pages 5

Food Injustice In America

Analysis of quote: The inequality in access to supermarkets between black and white low-income neighborhoods is obvious, with black communities having to travel further for essential groceries. This lack of access adds additional financial strain and perpetuates…

Words 2436 - Pages 10

Casey Anthony Research Paper

15, 2008 Cindy Anthony, Casey’s mother, reports Caylee Anthony to be missing for weeks. On December 11, 2008 Caylee’s skeletal remains are found in a trash bag in a wooded area near the family’s home. Medical examiners initially ruled the death as a homicide due to duct tape on the child’s mouth. It was later ruled as “death by undetermined means”. Her trial lasted six weeks from May to July 2011. The verdict, as said earlier,…

Words 692 - Pages 3

OBST510 Bookreview2 Walton Essay

the audience an appendix of images used in this published work as well as gives his acknowledgements accompanied by a list of abbreviations. The author uses several contemporary studies as a big part of his research as well as reviews the ancient and Near Eastern and Israelite cognitive context. This section provides a general guidance for students and the audience to have a better understanding by expanding their knowledge of today’s culture, and historical culture and the way it interacts with the…

Words 4312 - Pages 18

Divergent Ethical Dilemma Essay

the ethical analysis of an ethical dilemma placated in the story. As the paper digresses, it focuses on the argument about the theory pertaining to the dilemma, the theories used and the counter argument that could be presented. The ethical dilemma begins with Tris running from three Dauntless simulation controlled soldiers where she is faced to a friendly face, Will. This ethical dilemma is prominent to the story. Because the grief Tris is already feeling, due to her mother’s death, it is increased…

Words 1835 - Pages 8

Do Violent Video Games Lead To Real Violence?

games, is helping the argument that video game violence translates into real-world situations. But other people aren't convinced and insist that video games are a scapegoat for a shocking social trend that has people scared and looking to place blame. Entertainment media has always made a great scapegoat: In the 1950s, lots of people blamed comic books for kids' bad behavior [source: CBS News]. Video games as we now know them are only about 20 years old, so there's nowhere near the amount of empirical…

Words 960 - Pages 4

Hamlet Essay

who we are in this world. Among us today this fear is as strong, and perhaps stronger, than it ever was. In fact, it is the common man who knows this fear best. (Miller, 2). _________________________________________________ Arthur Millers argument of the play Hamlet written by William Shakespeare shows how the fear of being broken away from the characters specific views are a huge fear. This fear is often strong possessing characters to act irrationally to keep their viewed position in the…

Words 1329 - Pages 6

Origen Of Alexandria Research Paper

opinions regarding the faith and each group claimed that each possessed the correct knowledge. Origen proved, through many trials and tribulations, to be influential, caring, and diligent in his mission to pursue Christ. Origen was born around 185 A.D. near Alexandria (Origen.) During this time the stability of the Roman Empire was threatened by barbarian invasions and Christian persecution (Moore Origen of Alexandria.) He was the oldest child of seven and was raised in a Christian home. He was well educated…

Words 906 - Pages 4

Children V Desormeaux Case Summary

was dismissed by all three courts. The reasons for the dismissing the claim against the Hosts varied, thus, the following analysis will critically assess and review the variation. The trial judge, Chadwick J., claimed that the case did give rise to a duty of care. He found that the Hosts had a duty not to turn Desormeaux loose on the highway where could cause injury or death to others. In my opinion, Chadwick was right to argue in favor of a possible foreseeability that Desormeaux could injure or…

Words 1463 - Pages 6